# \[PROPOSAL\] GRAPE DAO REWARDS: Bounty Template **URL:** \ **Category:** Bounty\ **Tags:** bounty\ **Created:** [April 15, 2022, 12:48pm UTC](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/t/proposal-grape-dao-rewards-bounty-template/913 "2022-04-15T12:48:01Z")\ **Posts on this page:** 8\ **Page:** 1
**Author:** ![Arximedis](https://yyz1.discourse-cdn.com/flex031/user_avatar/dao.grapenetwork.org/arximedis/32/515_2.png) [@Arximedis](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/u/Arximedis)\ **Post date:** [April 15, 2022, 12:48pm UTC](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/t/proposal-grape-dao-rewards-bounty-template/913/1 "2022-04-15T12:48:01Z")
**Type:** `Article` **Title:** `Measuring Decentralization or “DAOiness” of DAOs` **Funding:** `Pre-Funded` **Max Reward (Complete):**`150,000 $GRAPE` **Date Created:** `04/14/22` **Date Complete:** `05/31/22` **Restrictions:** `(Excluded Country/Topics/Projects/References)` **Language:** `English (default)` **Submission Instructions:** > Submit a link to your posted article below preferably hosted using Medium. **Description:** > What is decentralization in DAOs and how do you measure it? > > Provide arguments and/or metrics on how one can measure the degree of decentralization in Solana DAOs. Analyze DAOs using projects on Realms.today and statistics/metrics on [DeepDAO.io](http://DeepDAO.io) to support your thesis and produce an article that analyzes and looks to measure decentralization in a DAO. > > _Suggested Guidance Questions_ > > 1. What are the types of DAOs analyzed? (I.e. Investment & Community) > 2. What kind of resources are managed in these DAOs > 3. Are there defined groups of people within these DAOs and how are resources managed in a decentralized way? > 4. What are the factors or variables that contribute to “DAOiness”? > 5. How can we measure decentralization for a DAO? > 6. How does the DAO work or operate? I.e. People, Products, or Processes? > 7. Are there any other DAOs or projects that are similar? Do you see similarities or common themes/practices among particular DAOs, if yes what are they? > 8. If the DAO has a community, are the community users rewarded? If yes, How? > 9. How decentralized are the processes that resources are used in terms of compensation for contributors’ work? > 10. What is the nature of the NFT/tokens and how are they distributed? > _If you clearly answer the above questions in your bounty article, it will likely do well._ Recommended Sources: > 1. [Solana Realms](https://realms.today/realms) [https://realms.today/realms](https://realms.today/realms) > 2. [DeepDAO](https://deepdao.io/organizations) [https://deepdao.io/organizations](https://deepdao.io/organizations) **Summary:** > GRAPE is a Decentralized Social Network that brought the first open-source verification service, the first decentralized NFT DeX, and provides a suite of DAO tools and products to the Solana ecosystem. > > In this GRAPE Bounty, completers are rewarded $GRAPE tokens for writing original, non-plagiarized, articles about decentralization in Solana Realms DAOs and other DAOs for supporting examples. Hunters may use research information from [DeepDAO.io](http://DeepDAO.io) website and Realms.Today but may NOT copy/paste info aimlessly. Read the rules, there is other information that must be included. > > GRAPE has deposited 100% of the funds for Creation & Completion in advance. This bounty campaign is fully pre-funded. **Deliverable:** > Create an original article about how to measure decentralization or “DAOiness” of at least one Solana Realms DAO, with the support of metrics from DeepDAO. **Acceptance Criteria:** > Quality is based on amount of copied material, amount of technical/grammatical errors, overall impression, amount of images/pictures, and reach of article (comments/shares). Hunters may use research information from Solana Realms, DeepDAO, the DAO project analyzed, such as whitepapers or other documentation, but may not just rephrase line by line. > > Exceptional quality generally means no technical errors, minimal spelling/grammatical errors, little to no copy/paste of information, contains appropriate references to analyzed DAO’s, where at least one is a Solana Realms DAO, with reference to the DAO’s website, tools or other documentation, DeepDAO analyses, and contains relevant image(s) to support analyses. Rules > 1. Submissions may not promote the host or tokens as an investment. Any submissions which do are in violation and will be rejected. NO FINANCIAL ADVICE > 2. Article must be at least 2,000+ words. > 3. Article must be written in English. (Optional: additional translations from English) > 4. Article must be publicly viewable. > 5. Maximum Submission per member/user: One (1) > 6. Articles must contain at least one reference to the project being analyzed and appropriate references to other content used > 7. If Discord user, must include Discord Profile Name at bottom of article. > 8. Article platforms: Medium > 9. Do not publish to Reddit, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat or other Social Network > 10. Once submitted you agree to give over all intellectual and publishing rights of submitted articles to GRAPE. Disqualification Reasons: copied/plagiarized content, broken links, empty articles, or anything as a placeholder. These are all strict rule violations, and disqualifies you from any reward in the GRAPE Bounty in general. Thanks to @Dim_Selk @Takisoul for helping to create this Bounty & @DeanMachine for allowing us to use the term “DAOiness”. ---
**Author:** ![CryptoPawz](https://yyz1.discourse-cdn.com/flex031/user_avatar/dao.grapenetwork.org/cryptopawz/32/53_2.png) [@CryptoPawz](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/u/CryptoPawz)\ **Post date:** [April 17, 2022, 10:44am UTC](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/t/proposal-grape-dao-rewards-bounty-template/913/2 "2022-04-17T10:44:24Z")
An amendment proposal made by GodsloveDAO on [Discord](https://ptb.discord.com/channels/837189238289203201/924724806421737534/964693644634378240). > [@GodsloveDAO](#): > > **Suggested Amendments to the Bounty Program** > > I would like to recommend the below proposed amendments to Bounty Pool Governance > > 1. Create a role of Bounty Governance Manager: > Role is to > a) standardize, update and organize the bounty submission/selection/reward structure. > b) Coordinate bounty feedback with those that submit it > c) Create a framework to judge completion of the bounty based on a GRAPE accepted > standards system before being sent to the governance structure for approval. > d) Propose the funding the Bounty program needs to continue operation to the treasury at the > end of every epoch. > > This person to this role is selected by the board every election epoch(not elected). The role can > be held by a Board member. > [ Please ignore this if it is a technical limitation in reassigning people who can authorize the > multisig wallets] > > 1. Rather than the Governance of the Pool Bounty being governed by the same people in the > board and providing other people to participate in the DAO’s governance actions I would like to > propose the following structural changes > a) Instead of the members in Bounty Pool Governance being DAO Board members > themselves, the board members should propose three(3) members to take this position > every election epoch Similarly instead of subDAO leaders, the subDAO leaders would > propose a member from their subDAO to take this position In the absence of volunteers > the board or subDAO leaders can nominate themselves to the position. > b) A max of five(5) subDAOs send their representatives to for Governance. The initial five > subDAOs can be selected by the current board but in the future will be selected by a > framework laid out by the Bounty Governance Manager of the most participating five > subDAOs > c) A ⅝ (five out of eight) majority is needed to pass every Bounty Pool Governance > proposal ---
**Author:** ![riderinred](https://yyz1.discourse-cdn.com/flex031/user_avatar/dao.grapenetwork.org/riderinred/32/382_2.png) [@riderinred](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/u/riderinred)\ **Post date:** [April 19, 2022, 12:47pm UTC](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/t/proposal-grape-dao-rewards-bounty-template/913/3 "2022-04-19T12:47:21Z")
Has the Bounty Governance Manager been added to the DAO Core roles ? ---
**Author:** ![discolove007](https://yyz1.discourse-cdn.com/flex031/user_avatar/dao.grapenetwork.org/discolove007/32/439_2.png) [@discolove007](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/u/discolove007)\ **Post date:** [April 26, 2022, 3:17am UTC](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/t/proposal-grape-dao-rewards-bounty-template/913/4 "2022-04-26T03:17:25Z")
Here is a simple form for someone to fill out to raise a bounty. [Bounty Questionnaire (google.com)](https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSd6UzkSJ1Zc59XmV12qtGY5UiV3pBcbG2h1Mf9Eu5qHanRvBg/viewform) Please take a look and suggest edits. ---
**Author:** ![discolove007](https://yyz1.discourse-cdn.com/flex031/user_avatar/dao.grapenetwork.org/discolove007/32/439_2.png) [@discolove007](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/u/discolove007)\ **Post date:** [April 26, 2022, 11:46am UTC](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/t/proposal-grape-dao-rewards-bounty-template/913/5 "2022-04-26T11:46:19Z")
wanted to get it out before I slept. adding a bit more context now. Replaced type with ‘which subDao would best solve the bounty’ . might make it easy for someone to make a selection. Created a 'how difficult ’ question instead of a reward question. Might be easier for someone to grasp than the grape sums. Added a question to allow them to suggest who would judge that its complete. ---
**Author:** ![Arximedis](https://yyz1.discourse-cdn.com/flex031/user_avatar/dao.grapenetwork.org/arximedis/32/515_2.png) [@Arximedis](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/u/Arximedis)\ **Post date:** [April 26, 2022, 11:19pm UTC](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/t/proposal-grape-dao-rewards-bounty-template/913/6 "2022-04-26T23:19:16Z")
Would it make sense to add the following? Type: [Drop-Down] Funding: Pre-Funded or Pending Approval Proposed Max Reward (Complete): X $GRAPE We can embed this form into Discourse 🙂 ---
**Author:** ![cavicon1](https://yyz1.discourse-cdn.com/flex031/user_avatar/dao.grapenetwork.org/cavicon1/32/746_2.png) [@cavicon1](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/u/cavicon1)\ **Post date:** [June 14, 2022, 11:50am UTC](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/t/proposal-grape-dao-rewards-bounty-template/913/7 "2022-06-14T11:50:42Z")
GGqieUyW18ZForVxhYs6dttUVGELhATX6Hoj2KVTXvxK ---
**Author:** ![scientistjoe](https://yyz1.discourse-cdn.com/flex031/user_avatar/dao.grapenetwork.org/scientistjoe/32/651_2.png) [@scientistjoe](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/u/scientistjoe)\ **Post date:** [June 14, 2022, 12:39pm UTC](https://dao.grapenetwork.org/t/proposal-grape-dao-rewards-bounty-template/913/8 "2022-06-14T12:39:12Z")
CLcXVZpCwF9QH2aNjFhPSzyeUVifkP9W88WHwfe6sMww