You are not providing any measurable metric here.
Helping provide good and swift service to new users
How is this measured to distinguish better mods than others?
Fast response (is this a contest?)
Long response? (is this a writing contest?)
How do you define cases assisted per moderator for example?
help in fastening grape access setup
This is the easiest of them all: Setups assisted on, setups completed etc. This will require all moderators to participate in this process though because currently not all moderators help in setups. What happens to the ones that do not assist in setups? Are they not good moderators because of that?
This I think is the current consensus.